Writers are doing it for themselves.

Peter Cox, Founder

What Went Wrong With Authonomy

The Great British Bake-Off for Books Is Toast

56037160_toast

Released on August 20, 2015

I never warmed to Authonomy, writes Peter Cox, the website for wannabe writers run by publishing behemoth HarperCollins. Today’s news of its closure was, in my view, inevitable.

I wasn’t endeared to it partly because it gave me the uneasy feeling that the concept was loosely based around what we have been doing – for far longer and rather better – here with Litopia. With certain important, and ultimately fatal, differences.

It wasn’t hard to understand Authonomy’s appeal to aspiring authors. Here, in one easily-accessible package, was potential access to a major publisher’s editorial team. A dream come true! Forget about pitching to finicky agents – the velvet-rope bouncers of the literary world. Who needs gatekeepers in any case, when you can sell your book directly to the Big Cheese?

From the publisher’s viewpoint, the concept was beguilingly simple. Get the slushpile (for that’s what Authonomy really was) to do its own quality control. Toss into the mix every conceivable manuscript – dire, insane, mediocre and occasionally brilliant. The cream will rise to the surface as authors feverishly rate each others’ manuscripts in one vast Darwinian literary struggle for survival! The few scripts left standing can then be acquired and published. A cunning concept, eh?

Auth-Black-RGBRight there, I have a huge problem.

Forget about the fact that it devalues the editorial process to nothing more than a mere popularity contest. Yes, that’s quite a big deal in itself, but I have an even bigger beef.

Setting authors in competition with each other for an editor’s attention strikes me as a very poor plan indeed. It’s a sort of imbecilic extension of Ayn Rand’s Objectivism – the cracked political theory that continues to lay waste to many of Western civilization’s finest collaborative achievements.

Of course, Ayn Rand had little time for collaboration. She was all about rivalry, struggle, self-interest and the survival of the fittest. I think a place like Litopia would make Ms. Rand wince.

The truth is, authors need each other. We need each other to progressively hone our craft – and we need each other to chart a path through today’s perplexing publishing landscape.

We don’t need to be jealously set against each other in some bonkers version of the Great British Bake Off for Books.

Of course, I’m certain that there were many warm-hearted and generously-spirited members of Authonomy who will genuinely miss the community there.

To whom I would say – welcome to Litopia… you’ll fit right in.

Finally, please note. Litopia is not run by a publishing megalith. We are tiny, in fact. We singularly lack Mr. Murdoch’s deep pockets.

If you like Litopia – do please support us, to whatever extent you can.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Highlights from the Shop

Also in this series

Burning Books

Public Service Announcement

School of Velocity / Burning Books Format Changes
8768071602_744767fb06_o

The Sensitive Billionaire

The More Money You Get, The Thinner Your Skin Becomes
12798953_10153918069325409_4601801973294650549_n

For The Love of Film

Three Authors, Three Film Buffs, Two Directors And A Memory Of Jam...
14677624029_f81a156af9_o

The Dirty Dictionary

Not Our Fault – Honest – If The OED Goes All Potty-Mouth!
10151160_694265313952820_3751758003095052469_n

Skurvi & The Rebelles

Cheap Booze, Cheap Laughs And Punk Rock
14750483096_38bbfbeb70_o

Salman Rushdie & Sherlock Homeboy

Plus Donald Trump & A Serial Killer...
9355232802_f88ccaca96_o

Dark Hunter Vs Shadowhunter

When Super-Colossal Authors Collide
ruts

The Ruts

Widely Regarded As One Of The Greatest Punk Bands Of All Time
3397453201_3ea1d43bee_o

The Icelandic Book Flood

From Havana To Reykjavík, It’s Raining Books... Muy Caliente!
2326464272_6a227698f7_o

Just A Man And His Will To Survive

Go for the ribs, don't let that bastard breathe!
13977048393_48f02569c0_o

The Adversary – Emmanuel Carrère

A Case of Mistaken Identity
loaded_44

The Best Track Of The Year

And The Winner Is...
HiRes

The Year’s Midnight

The World's Whole Sap Is Sunk
Money, Medicine & Marijuana

Money, Medicine & Marijuana

The Highs And Lows Of Legal Weed
7207729892_8311ba8903_o

Morality Play – Barry Unsworth

More Naughty Than Nice
11224118_846949912082289_1095269295991185283_n
4292385597_da36bce81b_o

Latecomers – Anita Brookner

Never Started Before It Was Over
m-r-hall

Ripped Off By The BBC?

Does The World’s Oldest Public Service Broadcaster Nick Ideas From Authors?
Millie Manders

Garry Johnson & Nick Welsh

How To Punk The Tabloid Newspapers For 15 Years!
hugh_cornwall

Whatever Happened To… The Stranglers?

Altogether Now... No More Heroes Any More...
11218933_896833570399762_9058062177095531222_n

Women Who Rock – Pride, Passion & Prejudice

It's Different For Girls... Rock-Climbing For Women
4591689772_8e7303fcf9_o

The Scapegoat – Sophia Nikolaidou

When the World is Against You
mona

Of Headscarves & Hymens: A Candid Conversation With Mona Eltahawy

Bruised, Defiant – Just Don’t Try Rescuing Her
10897107_911129542244517_192592394136801378_n

The Graveltones & Harry St Jimmy Adams

Your Monthly Smörgåsbord Of The Best In New Alternative Music!
Steve-Diggle

Steve Diggle – Still A Buzz, Cock

A Tour-De-Force Of Punks On Tour
5ae702_f943ae40839f4095a01a459c39a0b4ca.jpg_srb_p_759_480_75_22_0.50_1.20_0.00_jpg_srb

Patti Boulaye: From Strife To Stardom

All She Wanted Was To Be A Nun... But She Ended Up A Star Instead
debriefeer

Serial Killers of the World Unite!

You Have Nothing To Lose But Your Reputation...
2044161955_ba7b9c4d78_o

Gender Discrimination in Publishing

Looks Like It’s Tougher For Women To Get Published Than Men
The Cargo Cult of Europe

The Cargo Cult of Europe

In Or Out? Gal Shakes It All About With Socialist Brian Denny
Abdel Bari Atwan

The Hard Conversation

Enough With The Bombing. Let’s Talk About Peace In The Middle East
davidbowiepinup0

Flexipop – When Plastic Was Fantastic!

Lovingly Recreating The Zeitgeist Of The Nineteen Eighties...
iStock_000025646549_Double

Good Grief

What Does Grief Tell Us? Simply, That We Should Be Nicer To Each Other
Steven Berkoff

When Garry Met Steven Berkoff

Belching Fire & Spewing Brimstone, Berkoff Will Charm You & Bite Your Head Off
A Gronking We’d Rather Forget

A Gronking We’d Rather Forget

Yet Another Freaky Fortnight In The High Weirdness That Is Publishing
Out Of It

Out of It

Donna Takes A Blow To The Head & Everything Gets Weirder
The Retrospectives

The Retrospectives

Sheffield's Finest Give Manchester's Mightiest A Run For Their Money
The German Mujahid – Boualem Sansal

The German Mujahid – Boualem Sansal

The Secret Lives of Banlieusards
The Golden Years of British TV Comedy

The Golden Years of British TV Comedy

Colin Edmonds - A Scriptwriter At The Top Of His Game
11090909_10152827195272717_6233013514910465972_o

Electric River

The Band That Makes Garage Rock Cool Again!
8589591025_bb0739c46d_o

The Luzhin Defense – Vladimir Nabokov

Early Nabokov Trying Things
16275518230_90aed06947_k

A Gronking To Remember

Nazis And Puppies And Cartoon Terrorists, Oh My!
terry1

Terry Alderton – The Voices In My Head

"Exceptional, curiously lovable, & the sort of person you pray never sits next to you on a train" says the Telegraph